Fans' worst fears that the Ports would pay for a deadline error with the ultimate price of expulsion from senior status were confirmed on Tuesday by the Irish Football Association following Monday's meeting with the appeals panel.
Officials must now start the process of regrouping ahead of the proposed Premier Intermediate League - although the option of lodging a case with the Switzerland-based Court of Arbitration for Sport is on the table - but fans remain stunned and consensus is proving mixed as to the next step.
"As I see it, we must group together," said Nat Richardson. "We have suffered difficult times in the past but it is important to look to the future.
"I am convinced that a core fanbase will return to the club, even if it takes some individuals longer than others.
"Everyone is entitled to make a personal decision on the issue.
"If we expect the players to show a commitment to the club then the same goes for the fans."
However, a number of supporters feel let down by those trusted with guiding the club and feel measures must be taken to repair some of the damage caused to that bond between the board and terraces.
"Of course, the mistake was not a deliberate one but I cannot just move on and accept it as done and dusted," said Danny Elliott. "The fans deserve a full explanation as to why and how the deadline was missed.
"Rumours have been flying around but now is the time for answers and I think we are entitled to a meeting with officials.
TRUST
"It cannot change what has happened but it would go some way towards building up trust in the club.
"To be frank, the situation is a disaster for the club and the town."
Embarrassment caused by the mess may prove a black mark against the club's name within Irish League circles but some remain convinced that many still feel sympathetic towards Portadown.
"Although some will take delight in our downfall, I am aware of quite a few fans around other clubs who want us to bounce back," said Gary McNally. "I will continue to follow my team home and away next season.
"We must now move forward with as much dignity as possible and I do not think pushing the case down a legal route would help in that respect.

"There is no question that I am annoyed but we must accept the punishment and go onwards and upwards.
"The biggest fear is how this will affect matters on the pitch but if we can keep the squad together then I would expect Portadown to be in pole position next season to gain promotion."