Geoff Neill grabbed a goal but Bourneview Mill finished on the losing side in last weekend’s derby date.
Oxford Sunnyside held a 1-0 lead before Neill made his mark at Pepperton Park.
However, the visitors claimed a second ahead of the final whistle.
“We were slow to attack and got caught out on the break due to Oxford’s pace,” said a Bourneview spokesman. “Our best spell came around the equaliser, with Andrew Neill sharp in nets.”